“At one point when I was getting close to the ball, I looked down to see where I was at — if it was going to be a tough play,” Cuthbert said. “That’s why my first instinct was to hold onto the railing to not fall into the dugout. When the ball was coming down, that’s the only shot I had.
“Then the umpire said the runners were going to advance a base. I didn’t know about that rule. Every day you learn something in baseball.”
Watch the play here:
Rich Marazzi Expert Interpretation
Dugout Rule Requirements 5.09 (a), 5.06 (b) (3) (C)
No fielder may step into or go into a dugout to make a catch. In order to make a legal catch, the fielder must have one or both feet on or over the playing surface (including the lip of the dugout.) The top step or lip is considered to be outside the dugout.
If a fielder has one foot on the lip of the dugout and one foot on one of the steps of the dugout, he cannot make a legal catch.
If a fielder steps or falls into the dugout after making the catch, the ball is dead and any runner on base is awarded one base.
If a fielder drops the ball in his attempt to make a throw, the ball is dead and all runners are awarded two bases. This occurred in an Independent League game in New Haven several years ago. There was a runner on first base when the first baseman caught a foul fly ball and carried it into the first base dugout. He remained on his feet. The runner on first tagged-up and headed to second base. The first baseman, in an attempt to throw the ball, muffed it and the ball fell to the floor of the dugout. The umpires erroneously awarded the runner one base and kept him at second. The runner should have been awarded two bases because the muff of the throw is treated as a throw by an infielder into dead ball territory.
If a fielder makes a diving catch and slides into the dugout after catching the ball and ends up on the floor of the dugout, it is a legal catch. The ball is dead and all runners are awarded one base from the time of the pitch. In the Ruiz play he never ended up on the floor of the dugout. Therefore, the ball remained alive and in play.
Bench Personnel Assistance
If a fielder is about to fall into the dugout after making a catch, players and coaches from either team can assist the player from falling. It is illegal if a player, coach or manager from the opposing team interferes with the player and prevents him from making a catch.