7 or 9 innings?

  • Post
    Mark Astolfi
    Participant
    1165
    In August a 4-game series between the Cardinals and Tigers was postponed and only 2 of the games made up. If these games are needed to decide playoff qualifiers, they would be played in Detroit on Monday 9/28, ahead of the start of the playoffs 9/29.

    If only one game is needed, it would be scheduled for 9 innings…if both games are needed, both would be scheduled for 7 innings. But it’s possible they won’t know whether 1 or 2 games are needed until after the first game is played. So is the first game scheduled for 7 or 9 innings? I would say 7, since they are scheduling a doubleheader with the possibility that the second game could be cancelled due to it not effecting the standings, just as the second game could be cancelled due to some other circumstance, such as weather.

Viewing 0 reply threads
  • Replies
      Mark Astolfi
      Participant
      1165
      Wow, this is a roaring hot topic! Altho I see other posts that get zero comments, so what the heck. Maybe I just wasn’t saying it right…it is tricky. The point is, consider a situation where you are only going to make up as many games as are necessary to determine playoff status. And you don’t know whether it will take one game or two. If it would take one game, you’d play 9 innings…if two games, 7 innings. For how many innings do you schedule the first game?  And my answer was, since it’s possible you’d need two games, you schedule two games  for 7 innings each, then cancel the second game if it’s not necessary. Trouble with that reasoning is, the losing team could argue that since you only played one game, it should have gone on for two more innings, during which time of course they might have won.
Viewing 0 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Don't strike out!

Become a part of the largest baseball rules community in the world!

Get free access to baseball forums, rules analysis and exclusive email content from current and former Major League Baseball players and umpires.