May 15, 2017

The New MLB Intentional Walk Rule

The New MLB Intentional Walk Rule

The new MLB intentional walk rule has had little effect on the overall length of major league games. It was not a particularly bold move, but it does represent a changing of the mindset of those decision makers to speed up the pace of play. The estimated time shaving is around 35 seconds per game.

Here is the official language from Major League Baseball.

Base on Balls

Definitions of Terms:

If the defensive team’s manager notifies the umpire that he would like to intentionally walk the batter,

  • Prior to the at-bat beginning: As the batter approaches the plate the umpire will call “Time,” the ball is dead, and the umpire shall award the batter first base and advance any other runner(s) forced to advance by the batter being walked.
  • During an at-bat: The umpire will call “Time,” the ball is dead, and the umpire shall award the batter first base and advance any other runner(s) forced to advance by the batter being walked.
  • If a substitute batter is being entered into the game, the plate umpire should confirm and officially signal the batter into the game prior to addressing the defensive Club’s request to intentionally walk the batter.

What Baseball Insiders Know That You Don’t

There are 24 multimedia search results for “walk” on
Sign up for full access to instructional videos, case studies, expert analysis, and rules disputes.
Use coupon code SPRING2017.
Click here for a special $29.95 membership – 40% off our regular price!

From a rules perspective, here are a couple of things to note about the new intentional walk rule:

  • Just as in the case of replay challenges, the manager must call for the walk; players cannot.
  • There is no set “sign” given to the umpire; holding up four fingers or simply waving the batter to first base is enough.
  • If a pitcher throws a few pitches to the batter and then the manager decides he wants an intentional walk, no problem. He may order the walk anytime.
  • The “ghost pitches” are not tabulated in the pitcher’s pitch count.
  • A team is not forced to use the “wave to first base” rule. A manager is permitted to instruct his pitcher to intentionally throw four balls out of the strike zone.

Over the years a few managers adopted what I refer to as the “unintentional – intentional walk. This is when the pitcher is ordered to throw four balls, but does so without the decorum of the catcher standing behind the plate with his arm extended straight out. Instead, the catcher hunkers down well outside of the strike zone and the pitcher obliges with four “misses.” Managers like Tony La Russa would employ this method because they didn’t want the hitter on deck to get extra motivated during intentional walk process.

The new rule, does however, eliminate the rare plays when the intentional walk is botched, backfires, is used as a smokescreen for a tricky play. Here are some examples of plays we will never see again:

Miguel Cabrera, playing for the Marlins hits the go-ahead RBI single against the Orioles in the 10th inning on an intentional walk.

In a youth game, July 5, 2010, between the Benicia All Stars and Sonoma Valley, a player hits a home run on an intentional walk pitch. It is absolutely crushed.

In the 1972 World Series, the Oakland A’s fooled Johnny Bench with a fake intentional walk that turned out an embarrassing strikeout for the Reds Hall of Fame catcher.

So, gone are the days when the pitcher throws four outside the zone while the watching public yawns and complains about the pace of play. But at least we have some fun memories of what used to happen when the intentional walk went wrong.

Official Baseball Rule 9.14: Base on Balls

Don't strike out!

Become a part of the largest baseball rules community in the world!

Get free access to baseball forums, rules analysis and exclusive email content from current and former Major League Baseball players and umpires.