April 25, 2022

Drop a Knee – When Can a Fielder Block a Base?

Is this legal?

Drop a Knee – When Can a Fielder Block a Base?

You see it all the time, a stolen base attempt, the fielder gets to the base before the runner then drops his knee, foot or leg in front of the base to keep the baserunner from touching the bag. Is this a legal play? What should coaches, players, umpires and fans know about the rule surrounding this defensive move? Chris Welsh and MLB, Umpire, Greg Gibson, discuss this and get you what you need to know about baseball rules.

High School Interpretation

(this is different than the pro (OBR) interpretation)

The interpretation at the high school level is different from OBR. NFHS rules require the fielder to be in possession of the ball before attempting to block the base. The call for violating this rule is obstruction.

NFHS 2-23-3: The fielder without possession of the ball denies access to the base the runner is attempting to achieve.

Comments

Mitchell and Magee

good video and discussion. Important that difference between OBR and NFHS highlighted

Jim Caudle

In my mind, the fielder must either have possession of the ball or be in the process of preparing to receive the ball. Intent is key here. Is he preparing to receive in order to make a tag? Or, is he trying to increase the likelihood of a putout by denying or limiting the baserunner’s access to the base. If his intent is the former, I would not rule obstruction. If the intent is the latter, I would rule obstruction. Umpire judgment must be applied on a play-by-play basis.

Leave a Reply

Don't strike out!

Become a part of the largest baseball rules community in the world!

Get free access to baseball forums, rules analysis and exclusive email content from current and former Major League Baseball players and umpires.