April 25, 2017

Red Sox’s Pedroia Spiked, Slide Rule Controversy – Again!

Red Sox’s Pedroia Spiked, Slide Rule Controversy – Again!

Manny Machado’s take out slide of Dustin Pedroia last week has stirred the cauldron of controversy that fingers MLB’s slide rule as the culprit. Pedroia is convinced Machado meant no harm with the spikes high, straight leg slide that forced him from the game and into an MRI machine. Don’t tell that to Boston’s Matt Barnes, who threw a crisp fastball behind Machado’s head later in the game. Barnes has been suspended for four games. Is this baseball? Or is this the result of a MLB rule that needs fine tuning?

Because Pedroia never attempted a throw to first base for a double play, the rule was not invoked. Even Joe Torre got into the discussion but upheld the umpire’s decision not to penalize the Orioles with a double play. According to the rule, there must be a deliberate attempt to turn a double play. Pedroia later admitted he was trying to get just one out. But if the rule was put in place to prevent injury to the covering fielder and this was not considered an illegal slide, then the rule is flawed.

When you type the terms “slide rule” into the baseballrulesacademy.com search engine, you’ll get more than 40 results of instructional videos, case studies, expert analysis, etc. – available to our members only.
You can get smart, too! Use coupon code SPRING2017.
Click here to get a $29.95 membership – that’s 40% off our regular price!

Watch the Machado–Pedroia play:

Read Rich Marazzi’s analysis of this play and see what rules changes he recommends:

Here is an Insider Report about the Utley – Tejada play that started it all! Includes 5 videos of dangerous MLB slides.

42. Willful and Deliberate Interference

Official Baseball Rule 6.01(j):

Don't strike out!

Become a part of the largest baseball rules community in the world!

Get free access to baseball forums, rules analysis and exclusive email content from current and former Major League Baseball players and umpires.