In a recent play, Cincinnati Reds left fielder Tyler Callihan demonstrates remarkable effort, catching a ball in fair territory before crashing into the wall and falling to the ground, causing the ball to dislodge from his glove. Per Major League Baseball’s catch rule, a fielder must hold the ball long enough to prove complete control, with any release being voluntary and intentional. Consequently, this play was ruled a no-catch. However, the ruling raises concerns among fans and experts, as it seems inconsistent to deny a catch when a fielder, after securing possession, loses the ball due to an impact with a wall or a fall. This incident highlights the need for Major League Baseball to review and potentially revise the catch rule’s wording and criteria to better reflect such scenarios.

Cincinnati Reds broadcaster Chris Welsh breaks down the play in this video.