The hidden ball trick in baseball can be a thrilling or humbling experience, depending on your role. For the fielder who executes this sly maneuver, it’s a moment of triumph. For the unsuspecting baserunner, it’s a lesson in embarrassment. Cincinnati Reds broadcaster Chris Welsh explains how to pull off the hidden ball trick, clarifies the legal and illegal actions involved, and shares notable examples from MLB games.

The hidden ball trick can however go horribly wrong for the team on defense. In August 2025, Manny Machado’s failed hidden ball trick against the Red Sox cost the Padres a run. With Jarren Duran on third, Machado tagged him, but pitcher Wandy Peralta’s position on the rubber caused a balk, scoring Duran. The Padres still won 5-4 in extra innings.